Addicted to Email? Your Brain Is Wired for It

Ever check your inbox “just once more,” only to find ten minutes later you’re frazzled, behind, and not even sure why you opened it in the first place?

It's not because you're weak—it's how you’re wired.

Email hijacks your brain because it dangles unpredictable rewards: sometimes it’s praise, sometimes it’s problems, sometimes it’s junk. That slot-machine effect triggers dopamine—the neurochemical of maybe, just maybe, this next one will matter. At the same time, every ping or chime sends a jolt of cortisol, the stress hormone.

Add in the myth of multitasking, and you’ve got the perfect storm for distraction overload. But here’s the good news: neuroscience doesn’t just explain why this happens—it also gives us a roadmap to reclaim focus.

Are you Addicted to your Email?

How much time to you think you spend reading or responding to email every day? Be honest. Recent studies show that the average office employee spends almost a third of the workday reading and responding to messages. That number is 10-15% higher for remote employees.

Email isn't just a time-suck. Checking email can become an addiction and easily morph into an productivity sinkhole.

In a recent Huffington Post poll, people were asked how much time they spend disconnected from email. Completely disconnected. No devices, no pinging, no vibrating, no pop-ups. Out of 1200 respondents, 60% reported spending less than two waking hours a day completely disconnected from email. Twenty percent spend less than a half hour disconnected.

Why Email Feels So Urgent (Even When It’s Not)

Your brain is constantly scanning for threats and rewards. An unread email can feel like both.

• Dopamine: Every “unread” icon is an unresolved loop—your brain craves closure.

• Cortisol: Alerts hijack your stress response, spiking heart rate and anxiety.

• Amygdala: The brain’s alarm system treats every ping like something that must be handled.

That’s why even if you’re in deep work, one notification can pull you out of flow in an instant.

It’s not just the quantity; it’s the range of emotions that email can trigger. Think about how often you open your email to something disappointing or troubling—a communication from a frustrated client, a “hair on fire” message from a colleague, or a boss that needs that report yesterday. Or what about the group messages with 12 people cc’d jumping into the conversation. Then, there are the nuisance messages. The ones that make you swear you’re going to unsubscribe.

Sure, there are some good ones – a request to speak at an upcoming conference, a vacation picture from your sister, or a few kind words of praise about your last project. It’s these positive, happy or fun messages, sprinkled in with all the rest that make email so addictive. They make us want to check our email again and again and again, even when we have better things to do.

Most of us are, in fact, addicted to email. Checking email looking for the good ones is shown to stimulate the release of the same reward and pleasure hormone, dopamine, that we get from other addictive behaviors such as sex, gambling, and drugs.

But, the negative ones are more dangerous. They do more than just steal our focus. They also generate stress chemicals like cortisol and norepinephrine that put you in survival mode. They shift blood flow away from areas where it might not be so crucial, like the thinking rational part of the brain.

Master Multitasker? Sorry… No.

Think you can answer emails while working on a project? Think again.The University of California, Irvine found it takes up to 20 minutes to refocus after switching tasks. Every time you peek at your inbox, you’re not just losing seconds—you’re bleeding cognitive fuel.

Multitasking isn’t just inefficient. It’s expensive. Your prefrontal cortex burns through glucose and oxygen trying to “reset” from one task to the next. Translation: you’re not just wasting time—you’re draining brainpower.

The more you bounce back and forth between tasks and email throughout the day, the more inefficient you get at each task. According to a University of California-Irvine study, we lose 20 minutes every time we shift our focus from the current task to our inbox.

Research has shown that just having your email program open in the background of your computer screen as you focus on another task, even if the window is minimized, can decrease performance. Checking your email in a physically separate space can actually make your incoming messages— and any attendant anxiety or urgency—feel more distant and less pressing. The more clear your primary work screen is, the more focused you are on that work.

🧠 Neuro Tip: Email is built on variable rewards—the same principle that makes slot machines addictive. Your brain doesn’t just like it—it can’t resist it. Awareness is step one. Boundaries are step two.

Further research shows that the stress of email overload also impacts impulse control. The stress generates cortisol and that increase of cortisol makes it harder for the prefrontal cortex – the rational, thinking brain that weighs actions against consequences – to do its job effectively. We’ve all been there… pound out a response to an email and hit send before stopping to think about how that message may be received or whether that message should be sent at all.

Productivity isn’t about pedaling faster and harder to keep up with a never-ending flow of information. It’s about being deliberate and efficient about how to spend your energy and focus. And it’s about reclaiming control over your inbox rather than letting it control you.

---